- Portals
- The Current Year
- ED in the News
- Admins
- Help ED Rebuild
- Archive
- ED Bookmarklet
- Donate Bitcoin
Contact an admin on Discord or EDF if you want an account. Also fuck bots.
Constructive Criticism: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
imported>Gray |
imported>Hagibor |
||
| (9 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ | {{stub}} | ||
[[image:Yantwtf.png|thumb | [[image:Yantwtf.png|thumb|[[R. Lee Ermey|What is THAT!?]] [[CAPS LOCK|WHAT THE FUCK IS THAT?!]]]] | ||
[[Image:JunoXinuhands.png|thumb|right|Look at how [[fail|good]] those hands are drawn!]] | [[Image:JunoXinuhands.png|thumb|right|Look at how [[fail|good]] those hands are drawn!]] | ||
[[image:ConstructiveCrits_torturedevice.jpg|thumb|right|I KNOW MAH ART SUCKS, I DO IT FOR FUN]] | <!--[[image:ConstructiveCrits_torturedevice.jpg|thumb|right|I KNOW MAH ART SUCKS, I DO IT FOR FUN]]--> | ||
'''Constructive criticism''' is perhaps one of the lulziest forms of trolling on the internet, particularly in online [[shitholes]] much like [[DeviantART]], where people submit their work online. | |||
In constructive criticism, one looks at artwork and finds its [[truth|flaws]] and [[lies|merits]] (ignoring this is what makes you a troll), which normally results in the offended [[Wambulance|rallying]] their friends to try and intimidate said critic into kissing the victim's ass. | |||
In constructive criticism, one looks at artwork and finds its [[truth|flaws]] and [[lies|merits]] (ignoring this is what makes you a troll), which normally results in | |||
Normally the constructive critic tries to play educator, offering tidbits on anatomy, lighting, color theory and all other components that make art good. The original idea behind the concept was to be a supportive collaborator that kindly and politely improves them through deconstructive analysis rather than just saying "it's shit", but what most people really mean when they ask for "concrit" is "lavish praise onto me while maybe mentioning one teensy little problem for 'balance.'" | Normally the constructive critic tries to play educator, offering tidbits on anatomy, lighting, color theory and all other components that make art good. The original idea behind the concept was to be a supportive collaborator that kindly and politely improves them through deconstructive analysis rather than just saying "it's shit", but what most people really mean when they ask for "concrit" is "lavish praise onto me while maybe mentioning one teensy little problem for 'balance.'" | ||
As one can guess, offering advice is pointless as it will be ignored and you'll be the subject of many a call out journal on whatever art site you happen to be on. As a result, you should only offer constructive criticism for the lulz; in fact, given the right target, you'll even look like the good guy! The results of such actions do create some of the best drama in the world. | As one can guess, offering advice is pointless as it will be ignored and you'll be the subject of many a call out journal on whatever art site you happen to be on. As a result, you should only offer constructive criticism for the [[lulz]]; in fact, given the right target, you'll even look like the good guy! The results of such actions do create some of the best drama in the world. | ||
[[image:How_Not_to_Take_Criticism_by_kevinbolk.jpg| | [[image:How_Not_to_Take_Criticism_by_kevinbolk.jpg|thumb|An example.]] | ||
==Excuses shitty artists make when critiqued== | ==Excuses shitty artists make when critiqued== | ||
*"If you can do better then show me." | |||
*[[Fail|"It's my style."]] | |||
*[[Wambulance|"It is emotional art."]] | |||
*[[Newfag|"I'm just learning."]] | |||
*[[emo|How do you know what I'm feeling, they're my words.]] Used by the [[butthurt]] when critiquing poetry. | |||
*[[Prove me wrong|My teacher said it was good]] | |||
*[[13-year-old boy|"I'm only 13."]] | |||
*[[GOTIS|I'm leaving this site forever cuz none of you appreciate me.]] | |||
*[[Facepalm|"I don't care, it is fun this way."]] | |||
*"Look at your gallery, it's empty lol! You have no right to criticize me." | |||
*''Comment hidden by poster.'' | |||
*"I didn't ask for critique." | |||
==Gallery of Constructive Critique== | ==Gallery of Constructive Critique== | ||
{{cg|Constructive Criticism|cg1|center| | |||
<gallery> | <gallery> | ||
Image:Blueshinebutthurt.png|sparklewolf drama fueled by patchedtogether.com | Image:Blueshinebutthurt.png|sparklewolf drama fueled by patchedtogether.com | ||
Image:BSWandzanflamers.jpg|not butthurt at all | Image:BSWandzanflamers.jpg|not butthurt at all | ||
Image:CritiqueBullShit.JPG|Complete bullshit. | Image:CritiqueBullShit.JPG|Complete bullshit. | ||
Image:Styleisanexcuse.PNG|waja users see no problem in bad art | Image:Styleisanexcuse.PNG|waja users see no problem in bad art | ||
</gallery> | |||
| | |||
<gallery> | |||
Image:Letbadartistbehappy.PNG|she has a point you know | Image:Letbadartistbehappy.PNG|she has a point you know | ||
Image:Disneycantdrawanimals.PNG|All Disney film animals look like Goofy dog | Image:Disneycantdrawanimals.PNG|All Disney film animals look like Goofy dog | ||
| Line 47: | Line 53: | ||
Image:In_scifi_anatomy_doesn%27t_matter.jpg| In Sci-Fi, anatomy doesn't matter | Image:In_scifi_anatomy_doesn%27t_matter.jpg| In Sci-Fi, anatomy doesn't matter | ||
Image:Wolfedit.jpg|[[Fixed]]. | Image:Wolfedit.jpg|[[Fixed]]. | ||
</gallery> | </gallery>}} | ||
==See Also== | ==See Also== | ||
*[[ | |||
*[[DeviantART]] | |||
*[[Snapesnogger]] | *[[Snapesnogger]] | ||
*[[DivineAngel]] | *[[DivineAngel]] | ||
| Line 56: | Line 63: | ||
*[[Conceptart]] | *[[Conceptart]] | ||
*[[4chan]] | *[[4chan]] | ||
*[[Disagree]] | |||
{{da}} | {{da}} | ||
{{fanfic}} | {{fanfic}} | ||
Latest revision as of 07:30, 11 June 2017
Constructive criticism is perhaps one of the lulziest forms of trolling on the internet, particularly in online shitholes much like DeviantART, where people submit their work online. In constructive criticism, one looks at artwork and finds its flaws and merits (ignoring this is what makes you a troll), which normally results in the offended rallying their friends to try and intimidate said critic into kissing the victim's ass.
Normally the constructive critic tries to play educator, offering tidbits on anatomy, lighting, color theory and all other components that make art good. The original idea behind the concept was to be a supportive collaborator that kindly and politely improves them through deconstructive analysis rather than just saying "it's shit", but what most people really mean when they ask for "concrit" is "lavish praise onto me while maybe mentioning one teensy little problem for 'balance.'"
As one can guess, offering advice is pointless as it will be ignored and you'll be the subject of many a call out journal on whatever art site you happen to be on. As a result, you should only offer constructive criticism for the lulz; in fact, given the right target, you'll even look like the good guy! The results of such actions do create some of the best drama in the world.
Excuses shitty artists make when critiqued
- "If you can do better then show me."
- "It's my style."
- "It is emotional art."
- "I'm just learning."
- How do you know what I'm feeling, they're my words. Used by the butthurt when critiquing poetry.
- My teacher said it was good
- "I'm only 13."
- I'm leaving this site forever cuz none of you appreciate me.
- "I don't care, it is fun this way."
- "Look at your gallery, it's empty lol! You have no right to criticize me."
- Comment hidden by poster.
- "I didn't ask for critique."
Gallery of Constructive Critique
Constructive Criticism About missing Pics
-
sparklewolf drama fueled by patchedtogether.com -
not butthurt at all -
Complete bullshit. -
waja users see no problem in bad art
[Expand Gallery]
-
she has a point you know -
All Disney film animals look like Goofy dog -
Can't you see the perfection? -
Fuck your art school bullshit! Get off my page! -
calm down, it is make believe -
don't listen to those people who can't tell what you drew -
Critics don't know what they're talking about -
Typical response to critique. -
ENJOY YOUR BAN, DOUCHE
-
Well, screw art school! -
"Quality doesn't matter! It's the simplicity of art!" -
In Sci-Fi, anatomy doesn't matter -
See Also
|
Constructive Criticism is part of a series on Visit the DeviantART Portal for complete coverage. |
| Constructive Criticism is part of a series on Language & Communication | |
|---|---|
Languages and Dialects • Grammar, Punctuation, Spelling, Style, and Usage • Rhetorical Strategies • Poetry •
The Politics of Language and Communication • Media • Visual Rhetoric
Click topics to expand |
|